Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
Gizzi Erskine Hair and makeup: Juliana Sergot using Lancôme and Tigi Gin in a tin Observer Food Monthly Taste Test OFM
Hair and makeup: Juliana Sergot using Lancôme and Tigi. Photograph: Alex Lake/The Observer
Hair and makeup: Juliana Sergot using Lancôme and Tigi. Photograph: Alex Lake/The Observer

Taste test: wines and cocktails in cans

This article is more than 4 years old

Cookery writer Gizzi Erskine tastes and rates high-street sparkling rosés, mojitos and gins in tins

Mojitos

Captain Morgan white rum mojito

250ml, £2, ocado.com
Wow! A good balance between acidity, sweetness, mint and alcohol. A really delicious mojito. Multi-layered, I’m even getting the caramel rum flavour. My favourite by a mile.
★★★★

Authentic Cocktail mojito

250ml, £1, morrisons.com
This has an overwhelming minty flavour, very sweet. It has a natural mint flavour, though. Not enough acidity and I can’t taste the alcohol.

Marks & Spencer mojito

250ml, £2, marksandspencer.com
This feels more alcoholic than the rest, and lacks acidity. Really boozy. Good rum flavour, though … rum and caramel are the overriding flavours.

Bacardi mojito

250ml, £1.80, ocado.com
Urgh! Is this a mojito? There’s nothing mojito about it. It has an astringent mint-like flavour. I can’t taste the alcohol.

Sparkling rosés

The Uncommon bubbly rosé

250ml, £5.99, selfridges.com
Dry and sharp. Very pale, with a nice fizz. There’s a white wine tinge to the flavour. My favourite of the bunch.
★★★★

I Heart rosé frizzante

200ml, £2.25, sainsburys.com
It’s got very fine bubbles, it’s very viscous. This tastes the most refined and big-bodied of the bunch ... it tastes expensive.
★★★★

Castellore rosé frizzante

200ml, £1.69, aldi.co.uk
Very berry ... strawberry and apricot notes. Rounded, with body. But it has an iron aftertaste, almost like the can.
★★★

Una rosé

200ml, £2, asda.com
Dark in colour. Very sweet. It’s like it has a slight vanilla tinge to it. Big rosé flavour. It’s got very big bubbles, tastes overly carbonated.
★★

Rosés

Mirabeau pret-a-porter rosé

250ml, £3.49, waitrose.com
This has got the lightness I look for in a rosé and something interesting going on behind it. This is quite nice. Seems alcoholic for a rosé, though.
★★★

Vandra malbec rosé

250ml, £2.50, sainsburys.com
Really watery, it doesn’t taste of anything. This would be OK over ice. It’s not exciting, but a rosé everyone wants to drink.
★★★

Maris rosé

250ml, £2.80, waitrose.com
I am really getting the can flavour, it’s a strange, overwhelming taste on the first sip. Insipid, bitter. I’d almost put this in a cocktail. It’s characterless, no va va voom.
★★

Nice pale rosé

250ml, £2.80, sainsburys.com
This is really acrid, very tinny tasting; it almost tastes like blood. I hate it ... I winced when I tried it.
0 stars

Gin and tonics

Sipsmith Gin and tonic

250ml, £2.75, ocado.com
This tastes like a solid pub G&T. This is something I would buy. It’s got sweetness and body, it’s dry but not drying, and there’s citrus, too.I’m getting the traditional London gin flavour.
★★★★

Alfie gin and tonic

250ml, £1.50, morrisons.com
This has a lot of flavour ... it’s acidic, there’s a lot of citrus and a good balance of sweetness. It has a citrus-elderflower backbone ... a nice flavour that is the sweet fruit side of herbal, rather than herbal-floral.
★★★

Marks & Spencer gin and tonic

250ml, £2, marksandspencer.com
Smells more of gin than tonic … the aroma is juniper over everything else. I’m getting tannins from the quinine. It will do for a quick drink on your way home.
★★★

Gordon’s gin and Schweppes tonic

250ml, £1.80, ocado.com
I’m not getting much smell from this. It doesn’t taste gin-y at all. I can’t tell if it’s got anything jazzy going on. A very sweet gin and tonic … lemonade-y almost. Definitely been masterminded for someone with a sweet tooth.
★★

Gin and diet tonics

Tesco gin and reduced calorie tonic

250ml, £1, tesco.com
It’s got a real citrus backbone to it. Definitely got the dryness … a really crisp flavour. I like the quinine and juniper. Nice.
★★★★

Sipsmith gin and light tonic

250ml, £2.75, ocado.com
This tastes the most alcoholic of the lot, a lot more quinine flavour and dryness than the rest. I like this, the flavour lingers. It’s a decent gin and tonic.
★★★

Sainsbury’s gin and diet tonic

250ml, £1, sainsburys.com
Really fizzy, fine bubbles hit your throat before your palate. Maybe a bit alarmingly fizzy. Inoffensive, it’s not giving me any kicks.
★★

Greyson’s dry gin and diet tonic

250ml, 85p, aldi.co.uk
It’s really lacklustre and is certainly a diet product … it tastes like sweetener to me. It’s not got much going for it. It just tastes like a sweet, slightly alcoholic drink.

Pink gin and tonics

Marks & Spencer Think Pink gin and tonic

250ml, £2, marksandspencer.com
This is dry, there is acidity and a gin hit. It’s got that bittery-sweetness, with a tiny bit of fruit at the back. Head and shoulders above the others, more adult in flavour.
★★★

Greyson’s premium dry gin and tonic

250ml, 85p, aldi.co.uk
I feel like I’m on the dancefloor of a trashy nightclub … it’s not classy-tasting, but is certainly not as sweet as some others.

Alfie pink gin and tonic

250ml, £1.50, morrisons.com
It has an OK quinine flavour. It’s still very sweet, though. I can’t taste the gin, although there is an alcohol flavour at the back. Pretty disgusting.

Gordon’s premium pink distilled gin and tonic

250ml, £1.80, ocado.com
It smells like the Mr Men ice lollies from the 80s. This is the alcopop for grownups. You can taste the gin for sure.
0 stars

All products are blind-tested

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed