Manchester Arena Inquiry: Bomb victims were failed on every level, family says

Twenty-two people murdered in the Manchester Arena bomb were "failed on every level" by organisations criticised in a public inquiry report, a victim's father has said.

Bomber Salman Abedi should have been identified as a threat by security, the inquiry chairman said.

Sir John Saunders found there were missed opportunities to avert or minimise the "devastating impact".

Martyn Hett's father said the attack "should have been prevented".

Paul Hett, whose 29-year-old son died in the bombing, said it had been heartbreaking "to find that Martyn had just been in the wrong place at the wrong time".

In addition to those who died, hundreds more were injured when the Manchester-born bomber, who was of Libyan descent, walked across the arena's foyer at the end of an Ariana Grande concert and detonated a device at 22:31 BST on 22 May 2017.

The first of three reports published by the public inquiry, which began in September, levelled criticism at British Transport Police (BTP), the arena operators SMG, and their contracted security providers, Showsec.

Mr Hett said the organisations involved had a duty of care to protect his son and the other victims, adding: "This inquiry has rightly found that we were failed by them on every level."

"This atrocity should and could have been prevented, and 22 people would not have lost their lives," he said.

Sir John said it was likely Abedi would have detonated his device if confronted but "the loss of life and injury is highly likely to have been less".

On the night of the bombing the national terror threat was classed as severe, meaning an attack was highly likely.

The inquiry chairman said: "Whilst the threat was not specific to any particular premises, the arena was always a possible target for a terrorist.

"Everybody concerned with security at the arena should have been doing their job in the knowledge that a terrorist attack might occur on that night.

"They weren't. No-one believed it could happen to them."

Sir John found two teenage stewards did not react "as robustly and effectively as they should have" when a member of the public, Christopher Wild, raised his concerns about the bomber.

The inquiry chairman called this "the most striking missed opportunity".

Other key findings:

A range of improvements have been recommended.

Most notably Sir John has supported the introduction of new "Protect Duty" legislation to place a duty on venue operators to consider and cater for the risk of a terrorist attack.

Figen Murray has been campaigning for the legislation, also known an "Martyn's Law", in memory of her son, Martyn Hett.

She said the report made it clear that "venue security needs to be improved to help prevent further terror attacks".

"We should not have to live in fear and I am determined to make this law a reality," she added.

This report makes difficult reading for the families of the 22 people who were murdered at the Manchester Arena.

But everyone I have spoken to has said how important it is, and how valuable they find it.

Nothing in the 200-page document can bring their loved ones back but there is a united feeling they do not want anyone else to suffer as they have.

And so, they are committed to this inquiry laying out failures and suggesting ways to improve things for the future.

The families I have spoken to know that there is still a long road ahead and are particularly dreading the section of the inquiry which will examine how the 22 died and whether any of them could have been saved.

They know that there will be many more painful days like this one before they reach the end of the process.

June Tron, mother of 32-year-old Philip Tron from Gateshead, said she hoped laws would be introduced "to ensure people can go to a concert or a big public event in confidence that they have the best possible protection".

"It has become clear that was not the case for Philip, 21 others who also lost their lives, and the hundreds more who were seriously injured or left traumatised by what happened," she said.

She said it was hard to accept that "Philip and everybody else in the vicinity of the arena that night was placed at risk".

Solicitor Neil Hudgell, who represents some of the bereaved families, said collective failings made the arena a sitting target for terrorists, leaving thousands of young people "open and vulnerable".

"The security around the venue and event was nowhere near what it needed to be," he said.

Speaking on behalf of seven bereaved families, lawyer Elkan Abrahamson said: "It has been incredibly disappointing for our families to watch and listen as those with responsibility for the safety of their loved ones failed to accept serious shortcomings and inadequacies in the security arrangements and sought to avoid responsibility and push the blame on to others."

He added: "Prosecutions should be commenced without further delay."

Arena operator SMG said it would "continuously challenge ourselves to be better".

SMG added that, during the inquiry, experts "did not see evidence that the security operation in place at Manchester Arena was out of step with the operations being used at other comparable venues" but added that "this doesn't give us any comfort".

"Our guests came to the arena to enjoy a show but were met with a horrific tragedy. For that we are truly sorry," a spokesperson added.

Security firm Showsec said it had "learnt lessons" and improvements were "already in place" but it would now "take time to consider both Sir John's criticisms and his recommendations before responding as he has requested".

BTP Chief Constable Lucy D'Orsi said the force had been "reviewing procedures, operational planning and training" since the attack and was "committed to ensuring our staff are supported and prepared to undertake the roles they are required to do".

Home Secretary Priti Patel said the government continued "to take action in response to the terrorist threat" and had launched a consultation on the proposed Protect Duty.

She said the government would "carefully consider" the report and would respond fully in due course.

Why not follow BBC North West on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram? You can also send story ideas to northwest.newsonline@bbc.co.uk